The Hits Don’t Stop

Just a short stream of consciousness ramble today. The death of Overwatch Stadium has me feeling despondent about the state of my favourite hobby.

Pharah using her ultimate in Overwatch Stadium.I just finished writing a scathing column for Massively OP that should go up in the near future, so I won’t discuss Stadium specifically too much here, but it’s just another hit in a bad year. First New World was shut down, now Stadium. It hurts as a player, and it’s embarrassing professionally that I keep evangelizing for games only for them to fall flat. At least you can never accuse me of being a trend-chaser…

I’m too loyal for my own good, so this will probably pass, but right now I’m feeling so bitter at the mistreatment of Stadium I’m questioning my whole relationship with Blizzard. Do I really need to go back to WoW? Do I want to play Diablo 4 after all?

This time last year, it felt like Blizzard was on a redemption arc, with War Within being one of the best expansions ever for WoW, Stadium adding a whole new way to experience Overwatch, and Heroes of the Storm actually getting patches again. But now Midnight has torched Blood Elf lore (while admittedly still being a pretty good expansion outside the story), Stadium is dead, and Heroes of the Storm’s revival has turned into a monkey’s paw wish, with StarCraft II now also being mangled by bizarre redesigns as well.

Even beyond Blizzard, things are looking fairly bleak for gaming right now. There’s always been a lot of cynicism and negativity in the gaming community, but I’ve never been able to see things that way. I’ve watched the medium grow from crude DOS games to a vibrant and thriving artistic medium overflowing with diverse and creative titles, and I’ve always been continually awestruck by the artistry of indie and AAA titles alike.

My Syndicate main in New World.But with layoffs, cancellations, and closures everywhere, even my faith is being tested. I’m sure gaming will survive and probably recover, but it’s rough right now.

Part of it is just my depression and disability leaving me with little else to focus on in life, but I miss having things to look forward to. Genuinely the thing I think I’m going to miss the most about Stadium is not so much playing it as looking forward to what was coming next for it. Having a big and regularly updated game to look forward to is a good thing to focus on to keep my darker thoughts at bay.

There’s still WoW, but it just can’t excite in the same way after twenty years, even putting aside my conflicted feelings mentioned above. I was looking forward to giving ESO another go once they finish their class revamps, but now it’s been gutted by layoffs too, so who knows what its future looks like. I still want to give Aion 2 a try, but the more I read about it and its extremely sweaty community, the less appealing it seems. I’ve still got my Age of Empires games, but their expansions are relatively small and only every couple of months, and there’s no guarantee they’re safe from Microsoft’s layoff spree either. Once BioWare might have been a sense of hope, but after Veilguard (which I’m actually playing now), it’s hard to be optimistic about their future releases.

A co-op mission in ZeroSpace's beta,There’s smaller things, but they’re just that: Smaller. There’s Miracle, of course, but that’s years away, and likely to be a game I’ll finish in a week at most. There’s the unannounced yet seemingly inevitable Clair Obscur sequel, but again, far in the future. ZeroSpace is coming soon, but I worry it’s not going to get enough players to survive, and even if it does I don’t feel like it’s going to have the longevity SC2 did for me. I’m interested in Exodus, but the previews for it have seemed a bit mixed, and it’s still aways off.

It doesn’t help I’ve had a horrendous year outside the realm of gaming, with financial woes, health issues, and constant pain.

Nor is it improving my mood that the world is on fire, my city looks like it’s descended into literal hell, and I can’t go outside because the fucking air is poison.

I’m just not having a good time, man.

Growing Frustration with Stormgate

After an releasing an intensely mediocre Steam Next Fest demo, Stormgate developer Frost Giant Studios has continued to court controversy. The developers have caused confusion over what “fully funded to launch” means, they’ve flirted with the idea of using generative AI to run its story NPCs, and they’ve launched an equity crowdfunding campaign.

A promotional image for upcoming RTS Stormgate.I think equity crowdfunding is a bit of a dodgy road to go down in the first place, but what really raised my eyebrows is that in the documentation around said campaign they claim StarCraft II: Wings of Liberty was their previous release.

A screenshot of a Frost Giant Studios equity crowdfunding document, in which they falsely claim to have been the team to launch StarCraft 2: Wings of Liberty.This is problematic because — and I can’t stress this enough — Frost Giant Studios and Blizzard Entertainment are not the same company.

Yes, some people at Frost Giant are ex-Blizzard, but the extent to which they have anointed themselves Blizzard 2 is getting really questionable, and they certainly can’t claim to have been the same team that launched WoL.

I’ve seen some seemingly well-researched reddit posts claiming that almost no one at Frost Giant actually had a major leadership role in the development of SC2. Certainly as a long time SC2 fanatic I can confirm that the only names I recognize at Frost Giant are Micky Neilson, who is just doing lore and not even a full-timer at FG, and Kevin Dong, who only joined the SC2 co-op team well after its launch (and in hindsight co-op’s quality dropped significantly under his leadership).

When I think of the main brains behind SC2, I think David Kim, Dustin Browder, Chris Metzen, Brian Kindregan, and Valerie Watrous, none of whom are employees at Frost Giant to my knowledge. Metzen is supposedly doing some consulting for them, but we have no idea how big his role actually is.

A promotional image for upcoming RTS Stormgate.I’m generally in favour of not ascribing to malice that which can be explained by incompetence, and I think calling game devs shady is an over-used trope, but I find it really hard to frame Frost Giant’s claim of ownership over Wings of Liberty as anything but deliberately disingenuous.

At this point I’ve lost pretty much all hope for Stormgate. There’s just way too many red flags around the game, not the least of which being that its current version just isn’t fun.

It’s frustrating because the RTS genre really needs a new champion right now, and Stormgate seemed to be the best candidate. Age of Empires IV has stumbled a lot post-launch. Godsworn is fun, but too small to be the Next Big Thing. ZeroSpace and Immortal: Gates of Pyre both have great ideas, but I don’t think either has a very good chance to deliver on their lofty ambitions. ZeroSpace so far looks far too complex to appeal to casual gamers, Gates of Pyre has been all but silent for a worryingly long time, and both are from small teams with little to no mainstream name recognition.

I want to be clear I’m not saying this to hate on Gates of Pyre or ZeroSpace. I love the ideas both games have presented, and I would be incredibly happy to see both survive and thrive. I’m just worried they won’t be able to.

Still, I have more faith in them than I do in Stormgate at this point.