WoW and My Changing Attitude Toward MMOs

Lately, I find my feelings about World of Warcraft are changing, and it’s giving me a different perspective on MMOs. Two things have led to this.

My warrior socializes in Lion's Arch during Guild Wars 2's Halloween eventThe first is taking a break and playing other games, particularly Guild Wars 2 and The Secret World. These games both have the gear grind treadmill that WoW does, but in both cases, it’s a much smaller part of the game, and they’re generally much more friendly to a casual play style.

The second is changes to WoW’s design in Mists of Pandaria, also catering to a more relaxed view of the game.

The backstory:

Over all the years I’ve played WoW, I’ve basically played it the same way. I’ve ground gear at endgame in the hopes of seeing some raid content. Yes, I avoided raiding guilds and the culture of “serious” raiders, but I still wanted the content and the story.

So I’d just keep trying to get more gear in the hopes it would increase my chances of getting into a successful PUG. It created this sort of low grade but constant anxiety about the game. Gotta keep up with the Johnsons.

My bloodbathed frostbrood vanquisher reenacts the Wrath of the Lich King load screenIn contrast, when I played other games, I didn’t have this, and in some ways, that made me enjoy them a lot more.

Then came the implementation of the Raid Finder in Cataclysm. This largely removed the need for me to participate in the gear grind. I still need to gear up to be able to queue for the Raid Finder, but that’s pretty easy, and once I do, I can pretty much do whatever I want — including not play at all.

It’s taken until now for me to fully realize this. It took trying other games to get me to grasp that I no longer need to stress about staying competitive.

The joy of indifference:

There’s also the fact that Mists of Pandaria is, by any standard, a very easy expansion, especially when compared to Cataclysm.

I don’t share the community’s intense hatred of Cataclysm, but there is one thing about it I really disliked, and I didn’t even realize it until I was free of it.

My paladin tries to find a way to pass the time during the Spine of Deathwing encounterCataclysm’s difficulty had a terrible effect on the community. The increased difficulty made it a case of survival of the fittest, and there was no room for the weak. It made elitists of even casuals like me.

I remember obsessively checking my Recount to make sure I was doing enough damage. I remember inspecting every tank at the beginning of each dungeon to make sure they weren’t scrubs. I remember kicking many, many nice people from my groups just because they couldn’t cut it as gamers.

I don’t have to play that way anymore. I haven’t even updated Recount since 5.1 launched — though I’m sure I will get around to it sooner or later.

The point is this: I no longer care, and that’s a good thing. The only goal I’m still pursuing with any seriousness is the Wrathion legendary chain, which has me regularly valor-capping for the first time ever. Otherwise, I can play however I want, without worrying about staying competitive.

My changing attitude:

My warlock completes the first stage of the Wrathion legendary chainThese changes to WoW mean I’m essentially “done” with the game much sooner than I would have been before — heck, before I was never done; it was an endless treadmill. Some people might think this a bad thing, but I don’t believe it is. It frees me to expand my gaming horizons.

I’m still playing WoW, but I’m also playing TSW and whatever else catches my fancy. I even played some Diablo III the other day for some strange reason. But I’m not enjoying WoW any less. In some ways, I might be enjoying it more.

Blizzard seems to be of the belief that more time playing their game equals more enjoyment for the player, but I believe this is a flawed theory. I think quality of gaming time matters more than quantity.

By not feeling like I need to log onto WoW every single day, I appreciate my time with it more. I never just log on and sit around thinking, “What am I gonna do?” I play because I really want to, not out of habit.

My warlock showing off her town clothes in the Vale of Eternal BlossomsIf I’m being fully honest, the fact I’m no longer as enamored with WoW’s mechanics as I once was is also a factor. This is the result of playing other games, which I found much more enjoyable from a strict gameplay perspective. As I’ve said, WoW does feel a little archaic these days.

I could never give it up. I care too much about the world and the characters, and Mists of Pandaria is doing a very good job of rekindling that feeling. But it does leave me wanting more from a gameplay perspective.

As an aside, this is a great lesson on the importance of creating good lore and an engaging world. I like the game mechanics of Guild Wars 2 much more than those of WoW, but I’m playing WoW more.

I’m also working on lowering my expectations for what WoW is capable of, which I realize were unreasonably high. My love for Warcraft III and the years where I wanted to play WoW but couldn’t led me to put the game on a pedestal. I think I’ll enjoy it more if I accept it for what it is, rather than expecting it to be the gaming messiah.

How I became a game-hopper:

A Jinn in The Secret WorldThere seems to be a general perception among the MMO community that obsessing over one game is the right way to do things. “Game-hopper” is a term often spoken with a hint of derision, and the general feeling is that playing an MMO is like being in a committed relationship. I’ve even dubbed my series of coverage on other games “Cheating on WoW.”

(Expect at least one more installment of this series in the near future, by the way.)

But I’m starting to think this is a very flawed way of thinking. It makes sense for single player games, where focus on one and burn through it quickly before moving on to another.

But MMOs are a different beast. You never really finish them, and if you try to play one forever, you will eventually burn out. The truth is that there is no developer on Earth who can produce content faster than players can get sick of it.

Nor can one MMO satisfy all gaming desires, though some do an admirable job of trying. If you try to play one MMO exclusively, you’ll eventually get bored and want to try something else.

The Secret World's introductory mission in the Tokyo subwayI’ve come to the conclusion MMOs shouldn’t be thought of as an exclusive relationship. I’m thinking of them more as television shows.

I like Glee (less so since Quinn left, but I digress), but that doesn’t mean I want it to be the only show I ever watch. I also like to watch The Simpsons, The Daily Show, and the news. Similarly, I like WoW, but I also like TSW, and GW2, and so forth.

This is part of why I’ve come to disdain the subscription business model so much. It’s not practical for most people to maintain several subs at once. Part of me wonders if I can even justify paying for WoW when I’m not playing as compulsively as I used to.

I’m not saying my way is the only way. If you enjoy sticking with a single game to the exclusion of all others, that’s cool. But I will go out on a limb and say that “game-hopping” is probably the wave of the future for most players.

Horde paratroopers attacking in the "A Little Patience" scenarioI suspect this is a large contributor to the growing popularity of subscription-free games. Again, the “free to not play” argument.

What about you? Do you practice MMOnogamy, or do you prefer to sample from the buffet of gaming? Share your thoughts.

Edit: Apparently, this is my 200th post. Yay?

Blizzard News: HotS Cinematic, Ghostcrawler’s Hint, and 5.1 Thoughts

Starcraft II: Heart of the Swarm opening cinematic unveiled:

After the disappointment that was the Mists of Pandaria intro, the Heart of the Swarm cinematic has renewed my faith in Blizzard’s cinematic department.

This is everything the intro to a new game should be. It’s epic, it’s badass, the graphics are spectacular, and it provides a great story hook leading into the game.

Well done, Blizzard. Well done.

Ghostcrawler gets all mysterious:

In a historic first, something interesting came out of Twitter the other day. A fan talked about how each of the last two Warcraft expansions has introduced an utterly game-changing feature — the Dungeon Finder in Wrath and the Raid Finder in Cataclysm — and asked Greg “Ghostcrawler” Street what he thought would be remembered as Mists of Pandaria’s most influential feature.

The Great Crab responded: “We haven’t announced it yet.

Initiate baseless speculation.

GhostcrawlerFirst, it should be noted that unannounced means we know nothing about it, so this doesn’t mean the new character models or the dance studio or anything else that Blizzard has suggested before.

Several people have suggested they might relax faction barriers similar to what was done in Rift, allowing Horde and Alliance players to group and interact on at least a limited basis.

I would love this — just about the only thing Blizzard could do to make me happier would be announcing Warcraft IV — and it’s not a terribly unreasonable guess given current circumstances.

All signs point to the next expansion focusing on the Burning Legion, and the last Legion invasion saw the Alliance and Horde become allies. There are also those hints about the Army of the Light, and even Wrathion’s been talking about trying to being the factions together.

But I’m fairly confident this is not something we’re ever going to see. For one thing, Metzen has said quite recently that the Horde/Alliance conflict is integral to the Warcraft universe and will probably never go away.

Wrathion hints at Azeroth's dark futureFor another, consider how toxic the rivalry between factions is. In World of Warcraft’s beta, both factions could chat with each other, but the feature was removed because of how much harassment it caused. And that was before people had eight years to build up hatred of the opposite faction.

I’ve already heard some people say they will do everything in their power to sabotage any groups that involve members of the opposite faction.

And then there’s this little thing called player versus player to consider.

So it’s not likely to be cross-faction grouping. What else could it be?

Personally, I lean towards some sort of “fluff” feature that won’t directly affect progression or core game mechanics. Perhaps armor dyes or some other radical new form of customization.

I’ll probably regret this, but I think my bet is a player housing system. It’s something that people have been asking for since… forever, it’s one of the few major MMO features that WoW is completely lacking, and Sunsong Ranch is a strong indication they’ve been testing the waters for it.

My rogue working on her farm in Halfhill in the Valley of the Four WindsPersonally, I’ve never seen the point of player housing, but a lot of people are very passionate about it, and its addition to WoW would definitely be a big deal.

My other guess would be something to improve the leveling content somehow. A mentor/sidekick type system has been suggested, and I could also see Blizzard possibly adding some kind of Guild Wars 2-like universal level scaling. In other words, if you go back to Westfall, you effectively become a level fifteen character again.

Raid Finder for outdated raids is also something that has been suggested. I consider it less likely, but Blizzard has expressed an interest in it before, and it would certainly be a good way to get more mileage out of old content.

They could even potentially rebalance old raids to spread them out over a larger level range. Imagine if you could queue for a Molten Core run at level twenty.

Or perhaps we’re finally going to get that pony he promised us.

Birds soaring over the cliffs above the Krasarang WildsWhat do you think it could be? What could be as game-changing as the Dungeon and Raid Finders?

5.1 thoughts:

All right, this isn’t really news per se, but this is as good a place as any to post it.

I recently finished the 5.1 storyline from the Dominance/Shieldwall dailies. Thanks to a grand commendation and the human reputation bonus, I was able to finish both versions at almost exactly the same time. Being this was a major dump of new story developments, you just knew I was going to talk about it.

Obligatory spoiler warning.

I’m pretty impressed by this storyline, I have to say. I’m not a fan of how slowly new revelations were trickled out pre-commendation, and some of the quests were clearly just filler, but mostly, this was an excellent piece of story-telling the likes of which I’ve rarely seen since the Warcraft III days.

My rogue assists Jaina Proudmoore in purging Dalaran of the SunreaversThe most controversial part is obviously the Purge of Dalaran. I don’t really know how to feel about it myself, and I mean that in the best way possible.

I like how there’s no clear right or wrong side here. Both factions did crappy things, but taken in context, it’s hard to fault either of them.

The Blood Elves did betray Jaina and the Kirin Tor rather grievously, but at the same time, Garrosh would have just had them all killed if they didn’t.

Jaina was quite brutal to the Sunreavers, but considering all that she’s been through in her life lately, I’d say she showed remarkable restraint.

This is what things were like back in Reign of Chaos. No clear good or bad sides. Just a lot of flawed characters trying to do the right thing, and not always succeeding.

My warlock meets with Lor'themar Theron following the Purge of DalaranI didn’t think it was possible, but Blizzard has succeeded in making me like Lor’themar Theron. The “Lor’themar who?” meme may finally be on its last legs. And in general, this chain did a great job of rekindling my love for the Blood Elves.

I can’t escape the feeling, though, that I’m destined to be disappointed by the culmination of this storyline. The 5.1 story hints at great things to come, but again, nothing interesting can ever really come of the Horde/Alliance war.

Peace is impossible for the reasons I discussed above, and game mechanics prevent either faction from ever winning or losing anything significant in the war. I have to wonder, then, what conclusion the Mists of Pandaria story could have that would not be ultimately underwhelming?

I’m not thrilled with the daily quests required to unlock this story, either. For one thing, linking the storyline to the dailies at all feels a little weird when there’s almost nothing connecting the two beyond the fact they both involve the Alliance/Horde war.

Garrosh Hellscream prepares to ring the Divine BellAlso, while they were much less painful than the Klaxxi and Golden Lotus grinds, they still weren’t the best examples of daily design I’ve seen. It amazes me that Blizzard still thinks there’s something enjoyable about killing crabs for meat at a 20% drop rate, and I welcome never having to see the Ruins of Ogudei again.

(Off-topic: How did rogues get to be so freaking terrible? My warlock can solo four elites at once without breaking a sweat, but my rogue can’t kill a single spirit trap without blowing all cooldowns and praying she doesn’t pull adds.)

Still, all in all, I find myself quite pleasantly surprised by the quality of the 5.1 story.