Review: Defiance, “All Things Must Pass”

It’s hard to believe this isn’t the season finale.

A promotional image for Defiance“All Things Must Pass” is an epic tour de force that showcases nearly the entire cast of Defiance at their best and culminates in an intense cliff-hanger that could easily have been a worthy conclusion to the season.

It starts with Datak Tarr and his wife being abducted by mysterious assailants. They wake to find themselves chained in a silo. With no escape — from their captivity or from each other — they are forced to confront the flaws within themselves and their relationship. And for all that they are the epitome of Castithan ruthlessness, there is still some good, and perhaps even a certain degree of nobility, within them.

Meanwhile, Mayor Pottinger continues his efforts to woo Amanda, but things do not go entirely according to his plan. The short version is that Amanda is kind of awesome.

Having been rescued by Quentin, the matriarch of the McCawley clan at last returns home, and there was not a dry eye in the house.

Following the events of the last episode, Nolan finds himself lost in the wilderness. He knows that the only hope of stopping Irisa lies with Mordecai, with whom she shares a mysterious connection. But before he can seek out Mordecai, Nolan must drag a mortally wounded Tommy the many miles back to Defiance.

Running low on food, Doc Yewll is forced to return to the surface, accompanied by the EGO-induced hallucination of her dead wife. Along the way, she stumbles across the wreckage of the Kaziri and realizes that Irisa has woken it.

The cast for Defiance for season twoAnd Irisa at last brings her plan into motion, waking the Ark fleet to do what Nim Shondu could not: cleanse the Earth in fire and create a new paradise for the chosen few.

There really wasn’t any element of this episode I didn’t enjoy. Defiance’s greatest strength, its cast, is used to its full effect, but “All Things Must Pass” also has an epic sci-fi feel that Defiance has generally lacked. Once again, I am struck by how vastly this show has changed, and all for the better.

Of course, it goes without saying at this point that the Tarrs’ plot was excellent. An entire hour of nothing but Stahma and Datak would still be worth watching. All credit to Tony Curran and Jaime Murray for their stellar performances.

Similarly, anything to do with the McCawley family is quite welcome. None of their scenes in “All Things Must Pass” advance the plot in any meaningful way, but they’re all sufficiently powerful that I don’t really care. It’s all just very well done.

Doc Yewll is someone else who never disappoints. Her acerbic banter with her hallucinatory wife offers no shortage of entertainment. I would have liked to have seen a greater acknowledgement of the emotional impact of still having her dead lover in her head, but then again, Yewll’s a pretty tough cookie.

I’d say that Nolan’s plot was probably the weakest part of this episode, but there’s nothing wrong with it. It just didn’t shine as brightly as the others. It was nice to see him and Tommy finally find some kind of peace between them.

The town of DefianceTaken all together, “All Things Must Pass” is an excellent episode, and perhaps Defiance’s finest outing to date.

Overall rating: 9/10

Retro Review, Continuum Season Two, Episodes 6-9

You know the drill: Here be spoilers.

The official logo for Continuum“Second Truths”:

Here’s an episode I have mixed feelings on.

“Second Truths” sees Carlos investigating a serial killer who has popped up off and on since long before Kiera’s arrival. Kiera recognizes the case, having researched it during her career in the future. She knows that the case was never solved, and that dozens more are destined to die.

She’s determined to stop the killings — despite the fact she knows the victims are all pedophiles — but her frequent inexplicable leaps of logic and “lucky hunches” draw increasing suspicion and frustration from Carlos.

Ultimately, the purpose of “Second Truths” is for Carlos to finally learn the truth of Kiera’s identity. That’s where the mixed feelings come in.

I really like the idea behind this episode. Revealing the truth to Carlos is something that needed to be done sooner or later, and it offers to change their relationship in very interesting ways. This is a good thing for the show going forward.

But it could have been handled better. Carlos became too suspicious of Kiera too quickly. Last episode, he was the president of the International We Love Kiera Fan Club, and now suddenly he’s been pushed to his limit by her secrets and can barely bring himself to speak with her.

Kiera, Alec, and Carlos in ContinuumSimilarly, Kiera behaves rather erratically through the whole episode. She is reckless, and doesn’t even bother trying to come up with covers for how she’s getting her information. It doesn’t jive with her usual cool, calm, and collected persona. It’s especially strange that this is supposedly due to her desperation to save people whom no one in their right mind should really care about, least of all a parent like Kiera.

I think this plot should have been spread out over more than one episode. With more foreshadowing and more time to develop, it would have felt a lot more natural. As it is, I’m glad Carlos has been brought in on the truth, but the way it happened left a fair bit to be desired.

“Second Truths” also developed the Freelancers a bit, giving us our first glimpse of Mr. Escher, but we didn’t really learn anything. Kind of strange, really.

And it turns out Alec’s girlfriend is a spy, which surprises me not in the slightest. The only question is whether she’s working for the Freelancers or Liber8. I’m kind of hoping it’s the Freelancers, just for a change of pace.

Overall rating: 7.3/10

“Second Degree”:

Most of “Second Degree” revolves around the trial of King Weasel himself, Julian Randall. Carlos, Kiera, and Alec are adamant that he must pay for his crimes, but both factions of Liber8 have other plans, and Jim has been using the case as a glorified campaign ad, billing himself as the law and order mayoral candidate even when that couldn’t be farther from the truth.

Julian Randal in ContinuumThe main thing that struck me about this episode was how complicated things have gotten — not a word I would have applied to Continuum before now. Between two factions of Liber8, the Freelancers, the cops, Gardner, Kellogg, and Kiera and her inner circle, it’s quite a tangled political web. So many disparate schemes are bleeding into one another.

Mind you, this isn’t necessarily a bad thing.

The outcome of Julian’s trial was somewhat predictable, but seeing so many schemes and interpersonal struggles evolve kept things interesting. I’m also rather enjoying the new dimension to Kiera and Carlos’s relationship now that he knows who she really is.

The side plots were fairly interesting, as well. Kiera and Gardner on the same side for once was a nice twist, and I’m hoping we can soon start to get an idea of just who the Freelancers are and what they’re after.

Also, hot damn, Lacey can kick some ass.

Yeah, yeah, I know her character is named Emily on this show, but she’ll always be Lacey to me.

Overall rating: 7.4/10

“Second Listen”:

I was planning to give this episode a fairly low rating until the last five minutes or so.

Rachel Nichols as Kiera Cameron in Continuum“Second Listen” begins with Kiera and Gardner continuing their search for the body snatchers who have been stealing the corpses of time travelers. It proves surprisingly difficult, and every lead results in a dead end — emphasis on the “dead” part in some cases.

Kiera even turns to Mr. Escher, who claims the culprits are Freelancers and that he is not one of them (despite previous reports to the contrary), but even that doesn’t help.

However, halfway through the episode, things take an odd turn. Garza appears out of nowhere to massacre Alec’s roommates and kidnap him.

The problem with this episode is that it feels scattered. Both story arcs are interesting, but the split between them is jarring, and it doesn’t leave enough time for either plot to get the attention it deserves.

But the ending totally saved it. Most of the time, Alec is like wallpaper: he’s always there, but you rarely notice him. He’s a good and likable character, but not always memorable compared to, say, Kiera and her cyber-powered ass-kickery.

But man, when Alec breaks out of his shell, he is awesome. His panicked speech as Garza holds his life in her hands has to have been the single best performance, the single most powerful moment Continuum has produced to date.

The cast of ContinuumAnd only now do we begin to understand just what is going on in Continuum, why they were all sent back in time.

It’s Alec. Everything is about Alec. It’s all to change the course of his life, to ensure he becomes the man he should be and not the man he ultimately became the first time around.

It does feel a little jarring that Garza apparently knew all along that they were meant to go back sixty years, not six. It seems an obvious retcon… though her line to Alec when they first crossed paths last season could have been an early hint. But I think that was just crazy Garza being crazy Garza. Either way, it wasn’t foreshadowed enough.

On the plus side, the idea of her being Alec’s “fail-safe” is awesome, and it does add an extra dimension to what was previously one of the thinnest characters on Continuum. Retcon or not, it’s probably for the best in the long run, even if it could have been handled better.

Overall rating: 7.9/10

“Seconds”:

This is another episode mostly focusing on Julian. Though he may have been exonerated on charges of murder due to the interference of Travis, he finds himself hunted on all sides. Kiera and the department are out for his blood, and they’re willing to bend or break the rules to get it.

A wallpaper featuring propaganda for Liber8This was a weird episode, and I’m not really sure what I make of it. It seemed as though they were trying to make the viewer feel some sympathy for Julian, but that’s simply not going to happen. Forget what he will do in the future; what he’s already done is unforgivable.

I am very disappointed that Alec tried to help him. That does not reflect kindly on Alec’s character, or his chances of not becoming the monster he became the first time around.

On the other hand, it was interesting to see Kiera’s ruthless side on full display. It’s becoming ever clearer that the war between her people and Liber8 is not one of good versus evil, but merely a clash between two very dark shades of gray.

I can’t say I approve of Kiera’s methods, but I also can’t say I blame her too harshly. Julian is not deserving of any mercy, though it would have been a lot simpler and more effective to just shoot him full of truth serum and then put a bullet in the little weasel’s skull.

I did enjoy the drama and intensity of “Seconds.” A rare strong performance from Rachel Nichols.

On the downside, it’s pretty strange that apparently no one noticed Gardner going missing.

So, yeah, this was pretty weird episode. Plenty of good stuff, but also some questionable story-telling decisions, and some things that just flat out don’t make any sense.

Overall rating: 7.3/10